If so, the method is sloppy. The descriptions I have read of the pre-conditions for Gatekeeper participation have a giant hole in them; Eliezer assumed a false equivalence when he wrote them.
If you think people should actually care about the giant hole you perceived in the pre-conditions, you should probably explicitly state what it was.
If you think people should actually care about the giant hole you perceived in the pre-conditions, you should probably explicitly state what it was.