Ugh. There is no valid logic anywhere near these topics. If you’re not defining terms and making concrete measurable propositions, you can’t use logic as part of your reasoning.
The validity of a logical argument can be judged independantly of whether it is sound. I think for [2] this seems quite difficult as per AndHisHorse’s comment. Could you elaborate on why this is the case for [1] as well? It seems to me that the logic can be abstracted quite easily.
Ugh. There is no valid logic anywhere near these topics. If you’re not defining terms and making concrete measurable propositions, you can’t use logic as part of your reasoning.
The validity of a logical argument can be judged independantly of whether it is sound. I think for [2] this seems quite difficult as per AndHisHorse’s comment. Could you elaborate on why this is the case for [1] as well? It seems to me that the logic can be abstracted quite easily.