The Review Phase is a bit of an evolving process – I’m expecting us to learn over the course of the month what sort of reviews are most helpful.
One explicit update I made since last week is shifting the Review Phase from “write up whether you think this post should be included in the book” to “focus on providing information to other people who are evaluating the post.”
The “judge” mindset seemed to be outputting less useful content than the “provide information to help evaluate” mindset.
I do think including notes about what you think should be included in the book is still valuable, but is something it makes more sense to do after you’ve spent some time in “evaluate and add information” mode.
I do think including notes about what you think should be included in the book is still valuable, but is something it makes more sense to do after you’ve spent some time in “evaluate and add information” mode.
Yeah, that’s the central question for the voting phase, which comes after the reviewing phase.
The Review Phase is a bit of an evolving process – I’m expecting us to learn over the course of the month what sort of reviews are most helpful.
One explicit update I made since last week is shifting the Review Phase from “write up whether you think this post should be included in the book” to “focus on providing information to other people who are evaluating the post.”
The “judge” mindset seemed to be outputting less useful content than the “provide information to help evaluate” mindset.
I do think including notes about what you think should be included in the book is still valuable, but is something it makes more sense to do after you’ve spent some time in “evaluate and add information” mode.
Yeah, that’s the central question for the voting phase, which comes after the reviewing phase.