It seems like both you and Gabriel (below) have constructed hypotheses which make sense in isolation from certain relevant facts. In particular, there’s a large fraction of the HP fanfic world consisting of females who write things with BDSM aspects and a dominant professor Snape. For example a dominant Snape with submissive Hermione pairing is not uncommon. Presumably whatever is going on here is in part making fun of that segment of fandom.
(I dated a girl at one point who’s very much involved in the HP fanfic community and might not have picked up on this point otherwise. )
If not for Eliezer’s remarks that there was something serious in this section I’d think that that was all that was going on this section- just a Take-That! to the fanbase. Given Eliezer’s remarks I think he intended it to be both a Take That and also something else possibly along the lines of Alicorn’s hypothesis.
It seems like both you and Gabriel (below) have constructed hypotheses which make sense in isolation from certain relevant facts. In particular, there’s a large fraction of the HP fanfic world consisting of females who write things with BDSM aspects and a dominant professor Snape. For example a dominant Snape with submissive Hermione pairing is not uncommon. Presumably whatever is going on here is in part making fun of that segment of fandom.
(I dated a girl at one point who’s very much involved in the HP fanfic community and might not have picked up on this point otherwise. )
If not for Eliezer’s remarks that there was something serious in this section I’d think that that was all that was going on this section- just a Take-That! to the fanbase. Given Eliezer’s remarks I think he intended it to be both a Take That and also something else possibly along the lines of Alicorn’s hypothesis.
Yes, I too thought it was just a cheap joke at the expense of Snape/student fanfiction...