People’s judgements on music often amount to “The pattern in which your brain releases dopamine in response to music is inferior to mine.”
I can definitely imagine coming to love Beethoven’s Fugue (which I played in the background while reading this post & comments) because—it’s not fundamentally different to other pieces I’ve come to love. But I seem to be a neophile in many ways, and I’ve been exposed to certain types of music, so I count tastes as personal and I find the Youtube comments you quote to be ridiculous.
Re repeated exposure: The pieces on an album that start out as my favourites tend to lose much of their appeal before very long, and I might even skip those tracks; pieces that didn’t grab me at first become my favourites and keep their appeal for much longer. (I can only think of one strong exception: As a teenager: I loved Rachmaninov’s 2nd concerto from the first time I heard it, liked it more as I listened to it more, and continued to love it for years. I still play it in my head to get rid of an earworm.)
People’s judgements on music often amount to “The pattern in which your brain releases dopamine in response to music is inferior to mine.”
I can definitely imagine coming to love Beethoven’s Fugue (which I played in the background while reading this post & comments) because—it’s not fundamentally different to other pieces I’ve come to love. But I seem to be a neophile in many ways, and I’ve been exposed to certain types of music, so I count tastes as personal and I find the Youtube comments you quote to be ridiculous.
Re repeated exposure: The pieces on an album that start out as my favourites tend to lose much of their appeal before very long, and I might even skip those tracks; pieces that didn’t grab me at first become my favourites and keep their appeal for much longer. (I can only think of one strong exception: As a teenager: I loved Rachmaninov’s 2nd concerto from the first time I heard it, liked it more as I listened to it more, and continued to love it for years. I still play it in my head to get rid of an earworm.)