(I have some disagreements with this. I think there’s a virtue Ben is pointing at (and which Zvi and others are pointing at), which is important, but I don’t think we have the luxury of living in the world where you get to execute that virtue without also worrying about the failure modes Richard is worried about)
Whether I agree with this point or not depends on whether you’re using Ben’s framing of the costs and benefits, or the framing I intended; I can’t tell.
I think I mostly have a deep disagreement with Ben here, which is important but not urgent to resolve and would take a bunch of time. (I think I might separately have different deep disagreements with you, but I haven’t evaluated that)
(I have some disagreements with this. I think there’s a virtue Ben is pointing at (and which Zvi and others are pointing at), which is important, but I don’t think we have the luxury of living in the world where you get to execute that virtue without also worrying about the failure modes Richard is worried about)
Whether I agree with this point or not depends on whether you’re using Ben’s framing of the costs and benefits, or the framing I intended; I can’t tell.
I think I mostly have a deep disagreement with Ben here, which is important but not urgent to resolve and would take a bunch of time. (I think I might separately have different deep disagreements with you, but I haven’t evaluated that)
+1