I’d always read this series as Rationalist propoganda, and this chapter doesn’t really work in that light.
Dumbledore, I’d figured, represented the world’s Conventional Wisdom. Benevolent, on the whole, deranged, absolutely, and far more powerful than Harry could ever be. Harry and Co. can no more overcome him than the LW’s readership can defeat the billions of non-rationalists.
With that interpretation in mind I didn’t really doubt that Dumbledore could ever be guilty of something, but figured Harry would have to let him off the hook. People with good intentions do bad things but you can’t go all Steerpike, ya know? I sort of figured that this was confirmed in Harry’s speech to McGonagall about blaming Voldemort vs. himself. Heroic responsibility means save even those who have erred (and I can’t really conceive of Dumbledore/humanity being judged to have sinned save by error).
But now we have Harry teaming up with Lucius and Draco, ostensibly to take down Dumbledore. I figured Draco represented your smart friend that you are trying to get to be a rationalist, and Lucius their peer structure. Inducting them into the Conspiracy shouldn’t allow you to overcome the deranged and benevolent Majority.
I suspect that Harry is securing their agreement to investigate Dumbledore while, himself, believing Dumbledore will be shown to be free of malice. Basically the blood purity science experiment all over again. I figure his goal here is to bring them into alliance, just as he says to Draco. Once the Malfoys abandon Blood Purity there is no reason they can’t be allies to the Dumbeldore power structure, save for both side’s past sins. Harry is drawing Lucius and Draco into investigating one of these sings in the hopes of effectively explaining it away, which coupled with their renunciation of Blood Purity as a doctrine should allow the formation of an alliance.
Also, I’d like to add that its hilarious to watch all the characters try and figure out who HARRY’s enemy is. They’ve been listening to Dumbledore’s ‘Life Is A Story’ pitch a bit too much. If someone tries to have a girl sent to a hell dungeon and then has her eaten by a troll they don’t like her. They aren’t trying to impede the Hero’s Quest by Sundering his Fellowship, they are acting out their animus. I predict that Hermione’s framing and murder were about her, not Harry.
They’ve been listening to Dumbledore’s ‘Life Is A Story’ pitch a bit too much.
Seems likely to me that tearing this down will be the climax of the Roles chapters. Dumbledore is the big character we have left who hasn’t had a ‘meeting’ with Harry. And all throughout the story—referencing Gandalf and LotR, “that’s not his style”—Dumbledore has been about playing a role in a story.
Also, revealing Dumbledore’s secrets is one of the big elements of Rowlings’ book 7, and one of the things HP:MoR would have to deal with to resolve all the canon plots in Harry’s first year.
Facepalm, of course. I was thinking there would be a meeting along the lines of the previous private conferences—pretending to be wise in particular. Didn’t actually get around to checking which meetings had happened versus which characters I’d expect.
I think you are reading into it a bit too deeply, and making analogies where analogies aren’t. It’s a story, so read it as such. I am not convinced that, say, Lucius is meant to represent Draco’s peer structure any more than the amount which he is part of Draco’s peer structure in-universe (being his father).
Oh and one more thing: For Dumbledore’s ‘Life Is A Story’ pitch, think a level up. The character’s don’t know it, and they probably never will, they are just that, when all else is stripped away. In the end, at the highest level, their life is a story. Ponder that for a while...
In the end, at the highest level, their life is a story
I wouldn’t put it above Eliezer to find a way of having Harry be “the End of the World” literally by just ending the story somehow. But I can’t think of any explanation in that vein for destroying the stars, other than maybe breaking the ceiling in the Hogwards hall, which doesn’t fit. And style-wise it doesn’t feel right.
Hmm...a few thoughts.
I’d always read this series as Rationalist propoganda, and this chapter doesn’t really work in that light.
Dumbledore, I’d figured, represented the world’s Conventional Wisdom. Benevolent, on the whole, deranged, absolutely, and far more powerful than Harry could ever be. Harry and Co. can no more overcome him than the LW’s readership can defeat the billions of non-rationalists.
With that interpretation in mind I didn’t really doubt that Dumbledore could ever be guilty of something, but figured Harry would have to let him off the hook. People with good intentions do bad things but you can’t go all Steerpike, ya know? I sort of figured that this was confirmed in Harry’s speech to McGonagall about blaming Voldemort vs. himself. Heroic responsibility means save even those who have erred (and I can’t really conceive of Dumbledore/humanity being judged to have sinned save by error).
But now we have Harry teaming up with Lucius and Draco, ostensibly to take down Dumbledore. I figured Draco represented your smart friend that you are trying to get to be a rationalist, and Lucius their peer structure. Inducting them into the Conspiracy shouldn’t allow you to overcome the deranged and benevolent Majority.
I suspect that Harry is securing their agreement to investigate Dumbledore while, himself, believing Dumbledore will be shown to be free of malice. Basically the blood purity science experiment all over again. I figure his goal here is to bring them into alliance, just as he says to Draco. Once the Malfoys abandon Blood Purity there is no reason they can’t be allies to the Dumbeldore power structure, save for both side’s past sins. Harry is drawing Lucius and Draco into investigating one of these sings in the hopes of effectively explaining it away, which coupled with their renunciation of Blood Purity as a doctrine should allow the formation of an alliance.
Also, I’d like to add that its hilarious to watch all the characters try and figure out who HARRY’s enemy is. They’ve been listening to Dumbledore’s ‘Life Is A Story’ pitch a bit too much. If someone tries to have a girl sent to a hell dungeon and then has her eaten by a troll they don’t like her. They aren’t trying to impede the Hero’s Quest by Sundering his Fellowship, they are acting out their animus. I predict that Hermione’s framing and murder were about her, not Harry.
Thanks for reading this long comment
Seems likely to me that tearing this down will be the climax of the Roles chapters. Dumbledore is the big character we have left who hasn’t had a ‘meeting’ with Harry. And all throughout the story—referencing Gandalf and LotR, “that’s not his style”—Dumbledore has been about playing a role in a story.
Also, revealing Dumbledore’s secrets is one of the big elements of Rowlings’ book 7, and one of the things HP:MoR would have to deal with to resolve all the canon plots in Harry’s first year.
“The first meeting:
...
...Harry found himself, still in his pajamas, facing Albus Dumbledore...”
Facepalm, of course. I was thinking there would be a meeting along the lines of the previous private conferences—pretending to be wise in particular. Didn’t actually get around to checking which meetings had happened versus which characters I’d expect.
I think you are reading into it a bit too deeply, and making analogies where analogies aren’t. It’s a story, so read it as such. I am not convinced that, say, Lucius is meant to represent Draco’s peer structure any more than the amount which he is part of Draco’s peer structure in-universe (being his father).
Oh and one more thing: For Dumbledore’s ‘Life Is A Story’ pitch, think a level up. The character’s don’t know it, and they probably never will, they are just that, when all else is stripped away. In the end, at the highest level, their life is a story. Ponder that for a while...
I wouldn’t put it above Eliezer to find a way of having Harry be “the End of the World” literally by just ending the story somehow. But I can’t think of any explanation in that vein for destroying the stars, other than maybe breaking the ceiling in the Hogwards hall, which doesn’t fit. And style-wise it doesn’t feel right.