I think its underrated, if it hadn’t been sold as an adaption of Asimov I suspect people would have loved it as a moderately clever scifi thriller (in the same vein as minority report and the matrix).
It tackles a lot of themes in interesting ways that aren’t normally shown, e.g. I like that the main character is portrayed as a bit of a luddite, but thats not shown to be the best view; and it examines the social impact of robotics a lot more than normal. If anything it gives an optimistic view of robots and a grim one of humans, but YMMV.
I actually liked the movie quite a bit. The antagonist follows a really weird and bad strategy for the sake of creating an action movie (a much subtler take-over of humanity would have made far more sense). But I think it’s a decent stab at Friendly AI difficulty, in a way the general public can understand—you can give a machine several rules that theoretically make it perfectly safe for humans, but those rules can still have ramifications you didn’t expect, leading to actions you wouldn’t have wanted.
Agreed that if it wasn’t called “I, Robot” it would have been “better.”
I think its underrated, if it hadn’t been sold as an adaption of Asimov I suspect people would have loved it as a moderately clever scifi thriller (in the same vein as minority report and the matrix).
It tackles a lot of themes in interesting ways that aren’t normally shown, e.g. I like that the main character is portrayed as a bit of a luddite, but thats not shown to be the best view; and it examines the social impact of robotics a lot more than normal. If anything it gives an optimistic view of robots and a grim one of humans, but YMMV.
I actually liked the movie quite a bit. The antagonist follows a really weird and bad strategy for the sake of creating an action movie (a much subtler take-over of humanity would have made far more sense). But I think it’s a decent stab at Friendly AI difficulty, in a way the general public can understand—you can give a machine several rules that theoretically make it perfectly safe for humans, but those rules can still have ramifications you didn’t expect, leading to actions you wouldn’t have wanted.
Agreed that if it wasn’t called “I, Robot” it would have been “better.”