The allocation of money is unspecified in this version, but has nothing to do with anyone’s predictions. You don’t get more money by one-boxing. I’ll edit to make that clearer.
Thanks. Unfortunately, now I’m horrendously confused. What’s the point of choosing either? Unless Prometheus is apt to feel vengeful (or generous), it doesn’t seem like there is any reason to prefer one course of action over another.
My understanding is that you get $200 by two-boxing and $100 by one-boxing, but with the caveat that you were created by Prometheus, God of One-Boxers. The allocation of money doesn’t change based on Prometheus’s predictions, because by Omega’s testimony you already know what set of Newcomblike predictions you belong to: your choice is whether or not to subvert that prediction.
I one-box on standard Newcomb, but I’d choose two boxes here.
The allocation of money is unspecified in this version, but has nothing to do with anyone’s predictions. You don’t get more money by one-boxing. I’ll edit to make that clearer.
Thanks. Unfortunately, now I’m horrendously confused. What’s the point of choosing either? Unless Prometheus is apt to feel vengeful (or generous), it doesn’t seem like there is any reason to prefer one course of action over another.
My understanding is that you get $200 by two-boxing and $100 by one-boxing, but with the caveat that you were created by Prometheus, God of One-Boxers. The allocation of money doesn’t change based on Prometheus’s predictions, because by Omega’s testimony you already know what set of Newcomblike predictions you belong to: your choice is whether or not to subvert that prediction.
I one-box on standard Newcomb, but I’d choose two boxes here.