Transparent Newcomb is the same problem as Kavka’s toxin. You should take one box for the same reason you should drink the toxin after the millionaire gives you the money. Your argument would prevent you from winning at Kavka’s toxin: after you get the money, and you’re faced with the toxin to drink, it’s tempting to think that there’s no reason to drink it.
Transparent Newcomb is the same problem as Kavka’s toxin. You should take one box for the same reason you should drink the toxin after the millionaire gives you the money. Your argument would prevent you from winning at Kavka’s toxin: after you get the money, and you’re faced with the toxin to drink, it’s tempting to think that there’s no reason to drink it.
You’re not making the correct comparison. Drinking Kavka’s toxin after you get the money is like one-boxing after seeing the box is full.
One-boxing whether the box is full or empty is however like drinking Kavka’s toxin even if you do NOT get the money.
And since Transparent Newcomb demands the latter (one-boxing whether the box is full or empty), it’s not the same problem as Kavka’s toxin.