Human mind: complex. Cybernetic diagram of minds-in-general: simple.
Dude, have you seriously not read the sequences?
First you say that defining minds is simple, and now you’re pointing back to your own brain’s inbuilt definition in order to support that claim… that’s like saying that your new compressor can compress multi-gigabyte files down to a single kilobyte… when the “compressor” itself is a terabyte or so in size.
You’re not actually reducing anything, you’re just repeatedly pointing at your own brain.
Re: “First you say that defining minds is simple, and now you’re pointing back to your own brain’s inbuilt definition in order to support that claim… ”
I am talking about a system with sensory input, motor output and memory/processing. Like in this diagram:
That is nothing specifically to do with human brains—it applies equally well to the “brain” of a washing machine.
Such a description is relatively simple. It could be presented to Martians in a manner so that they could understand it without access to any human brains.
Human mind: complex. Cybernetic diagram of minds-in-general: simple.
A thermostat doesn’t have a “mind that predicts the future”. So, it is off the table in the second definition I proposed.
Dude, have you seriously not read the sequences?
First you say that defining minds is simple, and now you’re pointing back to your own brain’s inbuilt definition in order to support that claim… that’s like saying that your new compressor can compress multi-gigabyte files down to a single kilobyte… when the “compressor” itself is a terabyte or so in size.
You’re not actually reducing anything, you’re just repeatedly pointing at your own brain.
Re: “First you say that defining minds is simple, and now you’re pointing back to your own brain’s inbuilt definition in order to support that claim… ”
I am talking about a system with sensory input, motor output and memory/processing. Like in this diagram:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7a/SOCyberntics.png
That is nothing specifically to do with human brains—it applies equally well to the “brain” of a washing machine.
Such a description is relatively simple. It could be presented to Martians in a manner so that they could understand it without access to any human brains.
That diagram also applies equally well to a thermostat, as I mentioned in a great-great-grandparent comment above.