Given that we would very much like to influence government policy
Is this actually a thing that we would want? It seems to me like this line of reasoning depends on a lot of assumptions that don’t seem all that shared.
(I do think that rationalists should coordinate more, but I don’t think rationalists executing the “just obey authority” action is likely to succeed. That seems like a recipe for losing a lot of people from the ‘rationalist’ label. I think there are other approaches that are better suited to the range of rationalist personalities, that still has enough tradition behind it for it to be likely to work; the main inspirations here are Norse þings and Quaker meetings.)
Is this actually a thing that we would want? It seems to me like this line of reasoning depends on a lot of assumptions that don’t seem all that shared.
(I do think that rationalists should coordinate more, but I don’t think rationalists executing the “just obey authority” action is likely to succeed. That seems like a recipe for losing a lot of people from the ‘rationalist’ label. I think there are other approaches that are better suited to the range of rationalist personalities, that still has enough tradition behind it for it to be likely to work; the main inspirations here are Norse þings and Quaker meetings.)