The west has too much trade, too much communication, too much tourism to want to fight
While that’s a valid observation, similar points were made just before WW1… Also you did notice how one European nation, Russia, invaded another European nation, Ukraine, just this year—right?
the fact that the US gave Germany money for rebuilding in the immediate aftermath of WWII really is an unprecedented act of generosity.
Not generosity. The US was building barriers against Stalin’s European ambitions.
While that’s a valid observation, similar points were made just before WW1
Far more people have visited other countries now than in 1914. Having said that, once France and Germany were connected by trains it does seem a bit stranger that they would want to fight.
Also you did notice how one European nation, Russia, invaded another European nation, Ukraine, just this year—right?
And the Russia stock markets crashed afterwards. But the war in the Ukraine is pretty limited with only a few thousand casualties, if it wasn’t for the amount of trade esp. gas with Russia, the war might have escalated far more.
Incidentally, I’m not sure Russia counts as part of ‘the west’.
Not generosity. The US was building barriers against Stalin’s European ambitions.
I know, but despite that it still seems very charitable compared to the treatment of the vanquished in previous wars. If only the allies had shown the same wisdom after WWI...
[The Marshall Plan was] Not generosity. The US was building barriers against Stalin’s European ambitions.
I dunno, it also gave lots of money to Britain too, which is harder to explain that way. (And I just learned from Wikipedia it also offered money to the Soviet Union and its allies, though I guess it expected them to turn it down.)
The Marshall Plan was not Germany-specific, it provided money for rebuilding of the entire Western Europe. It also coexisted with severe restrictions on German economy during the first post-war years, e.g.:
Even while the Marshall Plan was being implemented, the dismantling of German industry continued … The first “level of industry” plan, signed by the Allies on March 29, 1946, had stated that German heavy industry was to be lowered to 50% of its 1938 levels by the destruction of 1,500 listed manufacturing plants.
Incidentally, Germany stopped paying reparations long before Hitler came to power. Not that that stopped various German governments from blaming Germany’s economic problems on them.
While that’s a valid observation, similar points were made just before WW1… Also you did notice how one European nation, Russia, invaded another European nation, Ukraine, just this year—right?
Not generosity. The US was building barriers against Stalin’s European ambitions.
Far more people have visited other countries now than in 1914. Having said that, once France and Germany were connected by trains it does seem a bit stranger that they would want to fight.
And the Russia stock markets crashed afterwards. But the war in the Ukraine is pretty limited with only a few thousand casualties, if it wasn’t for the amount of trade esp. gas with Russia, the war might have escalated far more.
Incidentally, I’m not sure Russia counts as part of ‘the west’.
I know, but despite that it still seems very charitable compared to the treatment of the vanquished in previous wars. If only the allies had shown the same wisdom after WWI...
The war in Ukraine started with Russia just grabbing an important and lucrative chunk of territory: the Crimea. The West said: “Um.. err… OK.”
What you probably mean is “not vindictive”. The US was following self-interest, not doing charity.
Depending on who you ask. Others would say that the war started with a US-backed coup against Ukraine’s democratically elected government.
Sure, I am aware of such people, but listening to them tends to lead to severe brain damage :-/
I dunno, it also gave lots of money to Britain too, which is harder to explain that way. (And I just learned from Wikipedia it also offered money to the Soviet Union and its allies, though I guess it expected them to turn it down.)
I thought part of it was Germany starting WW2 as a result of resentment at reparations, so a more generous approach was tried.
The Marshall Plan was not Germany-specific, it provided money for rebuilding of the entire Western Europe. It also coexisted with severe restrictions on German economy during the first post-war years, e.g.:
Incidentally, Germany stopped paying reparations long before Hitler came to power. Not that that stopped various German governments from blaming Germany’s economic problems on them.