I’m down for feedback on whether to do more of this sort of thing (it only takes me ~2 hours), how I could make it better for the reader, whether to make it a top-level post, etc.
I agree with your perspective almost entirely (for reasons basically building on top of what Zvi has written about at length before), so I would be a lot more curious to see what Ronny’s argument was during the debate (if he is okay with sharing it, of course).
I know you have referenced and quoted part of his reasoning, but it’s a bit weird to read a rebuttal to someone’s argument without first reading the argument itself, in their own words.
I agree with your perspective almost entirely (for reasons basically building on top of what Zvi has written about at length before), so I would be a lot more curious to see what Ronny’s argument was during the debate (if he is okay with sharing it, of course).
I know you have referenced and quoted part of his reasoning, but it’s a bit weird to read a rebuttal to someone’s argument without first reading the argument itself, in their own words.