Jadagul: I’m saying that Eliezer’s explanation of what a choice is is not a sufficient condition. You suggested some additional constraints, which I would argue may be necessary but are still not sufficient conditions for a choice occurring.
My key point, though, as Schizo noted, was that I don’t think the concept should be salvaged, any more than phlogiston or caloric should have been salvaged.
Jadagul: I’m saying that Eliezer’s explanation of what a choice is is not a sufficient condition. You suggested some additional constraints, which I would argue may be necessary but are still not sufficient conditions for a choice occurring.
My key point, though, as Schizo noted, was that I don’t think the concept should be salvaged, any more than phlogiston or caloric should have been salvaged.