I thought that my response to Carl addressed your second question rather than your first, and was planning to try to address your first. If you’d like more thoughts on the first question I can give them, though I think that my reasoning on this point can be inferred from a close reading of and reflection on my recent blog posts.
I’d be happy to correspond about these things: feel free to email me at jsinick (at) gmail (dot) com
I thought that my response to Carl addressed your second question rather than your first, and was planning to try to address your first. If you’d like more thoughts on the first question I can give them, though I think that my reasoning on this point can be inferred from a close reading of and reflection on my recent blog posts.
I’d be happy to correspond about these things: feel free to email me at jsinick (at) gmail (dot) com