This looks like it could work. A wordpress blog would probably be fine as well. Of course these options don’t let people get karma for participating which would be a nice motivator to have. A subreddit would be nice...
Would the discussions really undermine the regular business of Less Wrong?
People like making numbers go higher. It’s a strange impulse, I’m not sure why we have it. Maybe assigning everyone numbers hijacks our dominance hierarchy instincts and we feel better about ourselves the higher our number is. For me, it isn’t the total that I like having so much as the feedback for individual comments. I get frustrated on other blogs when I make a comment that is informative and clever but doesn’t get a response. I feel like I’m talking to myself. Here even if no one responds I can at least learn if someone appreciated it. If a lot of people appreciated it I feel a brief sense of accomplishment.
This looks like it could work. A wordpress blog would probably be fine as well. Of course these options don’t let people get karma for participating which would be a nice motivator to have. A subreddit would be nice...
Would the discussions really undermine the regular business of Less Wrong?
Do people really care that much about karma? I mean, once one had enough karma to post top-level posts, does it matter that much?
People like making numbers go higher. It’s a strange impulse, I’m not sure why we have it. Maybe assigning everyone numbers hijacks our dominance hierarchy instincts and we feel better about ourselves the higher our number is. For me, it isn’t the total that I like having so much as the feedback for individual comments. I get frustrated on other blogs when I make a comment that is informative and clever but doesn’t get a response. I feel like I’m talking to myself. Here even if no one responds I can at least learn if someone appreciated it. If a lot of people appreciated it I feel a brief sense of accomplishment.
Two thoughts which have probably been beaten to death elsewhere:
1) A karma system is a good way to provide cues to which posts are worth reading and which aren’t.
2) Karma points are a big shiny status indicator, and LWers are no more immune to status drives than anyone else is.