Whether someone learns advanced piano from a book must be at least as much down to whether they know intermediate piano up to the level the book starts at, as to whether the book is a good guide to advanced piano.
But those divisions of ability and knowledge are even less agreed on in self-help, so matching up where you “are” with a book is less easy, and whether someone else matched with any given book might not be of any real help at all.
This does raise the rather embarrassing question of how many of my self-help books I’ve actually gotten some good out of, and it’s something I need to evaluate.
However, the review filter I’m using isn’t exactly for identifying which books to look into. It’s for eliminating otherwise promising books unless they look very good, and I’m not sure that I’ve bought any books that no one has reported good results from.
Has that check helped you?
Whether someone learns advanced piano from a book must be at least as much down to whether they know intermediate piano up to the level the book starts at, as to whether the book is a good guide to advanced piano.
But those divisions of ability and knowledge are even less agreed on in self-help, so matching up where you “are” with a book is less easy, and whether someone else matched with any given book might not be of any real help at all.
This does raise the rather embarrassing question of how many of my self-help books I’ve actually gotten some good out of, and it’s something I need to evaluate.
However, the review filter I’m using isn’t exactly for identifying which books to look into. It’s for eliminating otherwise promising books unless they look very good, and I’m not sure that I’ve bought any books that no one has reported good results from.