I see no reason for someone to take this advice. Polyphasic sleep has been the norm in many cultures and periods of history, and one might be more inclined to advise, “Regarding monophasic sleep: if you’re under, say, 18, don’t. The effects it has on the body’s developmental processes are not known”
Polyphasic sleep has been the norm in many cultures and periods of history
I have not heard this before, even on web sites touting it. Reference? A quick Google only turned up sceptical comments, and “segmented sleep”, which isn’t what I’ve understood by “polyphasic sleep”.
Well I don’t have a reference handy, but the page you just linked to identified “segmented sleep” as a synonym for “polyphasic sleep”. It seems to be along the lines I was thinking.
What I understood by polyphasic sleep is the practice of “ultra-short napping to achieve more time awake each day”, the point being to get more productive hours per day. There’s no suggestion that segmented sleep involves sleeping fewer hours than normal, but it might increase the quality of the waking hours.
From La Wik on segmented sleep: “Peasant couples were often too tired after a long day’s work to do much more than eat and go to sleep”. I sometimes have days like that, whereupon I’m likely to wake once or more through the night. Maybe I should get up and meditate or something, instead of turning over and falling asleep again.
Well, yes; biphasic sleep (noon siesta) is the natural sleeping pattern beyond infanthood. For extreme schedules like Uberman’s, though, there have been lots of reports on odd cravings and the like — such as grape juice — that, e.g. contain elements the body would normally generate itself during sleep.
(Are you really saying that we don’t know the effects of monophasic sleep?)
I see no reason for someone to take this advice. Polyphasic sleep has been the norm in many cultures and periods of history, and one might be more inclined to advise, “Regarding monophasic sleep: if you’re under, say, 18, don’t. The effects it has on the body’s developmental processes are not known”
I have not heard this before, even on web sites touting it. Reference? A quick Google only turned up sceptical comments, and “segmented sleep”, which isn’t what I’ve understood by “polyphasic sleep”.
Well I don’t have a reference handy, but the page you just linked to identified “segmented sleep” as a synonym for “polyphasic sleep”. It seems to be along the lines I was thinking.
What I understood by polyphasic sleep is the practice of “ultra-short napping to achieve more time awake each day”, the point being to get more productive hours per day. There’s no suggestion that segmented sleep involves sleeping fewer hours than normal, but it might increase the quality of the waking hours.
From La Wik on segmented sleep: “Peasant couples were often too tired after a long day’s work to do much more than eat and go to sleep”. I sometimes have days like that, whereupon I’m likely to wake once or more through the night. Maybe I should get up and meditate or something, instead of turning over and falling asleep again.
Well, yes; biphasic sleep (noon siesta) is the natural sleeping pattern beyond infanthood. For extreme schedules like Uberman’s, though, there have been lots of reports on odd cravings and the like — such as grape juice — that, e.g. contain elements the body would normally generate itself during sleep.
(Are you really saying that we don’t know the effects of monophasic sleep?)
Yes, we really don’t know the effects of monophasic sleep compared to polyphasic sleep.
I don’t understand how that makes sense in context of your original comment.
I only made one comment; saying “yes” probably suggested more coherence with Thom Blake than there really was.
My complaint is naturalistic fallacy.
Erm, yeah, what Douglas_Knight said.