So, as soon as I saw the song name I looked it up, and I had no idea what the heck it was about until I returned and kept reading your comment. I tried getting claude to expand on it. every single time it recognized the incest themes. None of the first messages recognized suicide, but many of the second messages did, when I asked what the character singing this is thinking/intending. But I haven’t found leading questions sufficient to get it to bring up suicide first. wait, nope! found a prompt where it’s now consistently bringing up suicide. I had to lead it pretty hard, but I think this prompt won’t make it bring up suicide for songs that don’t imply it… yup, tried it on a bunch of different songs, the interpretations all match mine closely, now including negative parts. Just gotta explain why you wanna know so bad, so I think people having relationship issues won’t get totally useless advice from claude. Definitely hard to get the rose colored glasses off, though, yeah.
So, as soon as I saw the song name I looked it up, and I had no idea what the heck it was about until I returned and kept reading your comment. I tried getting claude to expand on it. every single time it recognized the incest themes. None of the first messages recognized suicide, but many of the second messages did, when I asked what the character singing this is thinking/intending.
But I haven’t found leading questions sufficient to get it to bring up suicide first.wait, nope! found a prompt where it’s now consistently bringing up suicide. I had to lead it pretty hard, but I think this prompt won’t make it bring up suicide for songs that don’t imply it… yup, tried it on a bunch of different songs, the interpretations all match mine closely, now including negative parts. Just gotta explain why you wanna know so bad, so I think people having relationship issues won’t get totally useless advice from claude. Definitely hard to get the rose colored glasses off, though, yeah.