I see it strongly as asking the wrong questions with the wrong moral frameworks, and using it to justify abominable conclusions and priorities, and ultimately the betrayal of humanity itself—even if people who talk like this don’t write the last line of their arguments, it’s not like the rest of us don’t notice it. I don’t have any idea what to say to someone who writes ‘if I was told one pig was more important morally than one human I would not be surprised.’
Entirely seconded; this is my reaction also.