I’m going to grant that my use of confused was mistaken and just rephrase: Physicists have a clear theory of sound. So why can’t we just say Barry is wrong?
He’d be wrong if he was talking about what physicists talk about when they refer to sound.
He’d not be wrong if he was talking about what lots of other people talk about when they refer to “sound”.
“Sound” is a word that in our language circumscribes two different categories of phenomena—the acoustic vibration (that doesn’t require a listener), and the qualia of the sense of hearing (that does require a listener). In the circumstances of the English language the two meanings use the same word. That doesn’t necessitate for one meaning to be valid and the other meaning to be invalid. They’re both valid, they’re just different.
If I say “you have the right to bear arms” I mean a different thing with the words ‘arms’ than if I say “human arms are longer than monkey arms”, but that doesn’t make one meaning of the words ‘arms’ wrong and the other right.
The analogy I’ve always appreciated was that my map has one pixel for both my apartment and my neighbors. So why do they get mad when I go through the window and shower there? It’s mine too, just look at the map, sheesh!
I’m going to grant that my use of confused was mistaken and just rephrase: Physicists have a clear theory of sound. So why can’t we just say Barry is wrong?
He’d be wrong if he was talking about what physicists talk about when they refer to sound. He’d not be wrong if he was talking about what lots of other people talk about when they refer to “sound”.
“Sound” is a word that in our language circumscribes two different categories of phenomena—the acoustic vibration (that doesn’t require a listener), and the qualia of the sense of hearing (that does require a listener). In the circumstances of the English language the two meanings use the same word. That doesn’t necessitate for one meaning to be valid and the other meaning to be invalid. They’re both valid, they’re just different.
If I say “you have the right to bear arms” I mean a different thing with the words ‘arms’ than if I say “human arms are longer than monkey arms”, but that doesn’t make one meaning of the words ‘arms’ wrong and the other right.
The analogy I’ve always appreciated was that my map has one pixel for both my apartment and my neighbors. So why do they get mad when I go through the window and shower there? It’s mine too, just look at the map, sheesh!