More generally, I think that if mere-humans met very-alien minds with similarly-coherent preferences, and if the humans had the opportunity to magically fulfill certain alien preferences within some resource-budget, my guess is that the humans would have a pretty hard time offering power and wisdom in the right ways such that this overall went well for the aliens by their own lights (as extrapolated at the beginning), at least without some sort of volition-extrapolation.
Isn’t the worst case scenario just leaving the aliens alone? If I’m worried I’m going to fuck up some alien’s preferences, I’m just not going to give them any power or wisdom!
I guess you think we’re likely to fuck up the alien’s preferences by light of their reflection process, but not our reflection process. But this just recurs to the meta level. If I really do care about an alien’s preferences (as it feels like I do), why can’t I also care about their reflection process (which is just a meta preference)?
I feel like the meta level at which I no longer care about doing right by an alien is basically the meta level at which I stop caring about someone doing right by me. In fact, this is exactly how it seems mentally constructed: what I mean by “doing right by [person]” is “what that person would mean by ‘doing right by me’”. This seems like either something as simple as it naively looks, or sensitive to weird hyperparameters I’m not sure I care about anyway.
Isn’t the worst case scenario just leaving the aliens alone? If I’m worried I’m going to fuck up some alien’s preferences, I’m just not going to give them any power or wisdom!
I guess you think we’re likely to fuck up the alien’s preferences by light of their reflection process, but not our reflection process. But this just recurs to the meta level. If I really do care about an alien’s preferences (as it feels like I do), why can’t I also care about their reflection process (which is just a meta preference)?
I feel like the meta level at which I no longer care about doing right by an alien is basically the meta level at which I stop caring about someone doing right by me. In fact, this is exactly how it seems mentally constructed: what I mean by “doing right by [person]” is “what that person would mean by ‘doing right by me’”. This seems like either something as simple as it naively looks, or sensitive to weird hyperparameters I’m not sure I care about anyway.