this does not obviously create in me an impulse to consult a brain scan readout or a table of my counterfactual behaviors
Sure, unless one of the semi-random considerations that moves you is “Crap, my EV is not coherent. Well I don’t want to lay down and wait to die, so let’s just make an AI that will serve my current desires.” :)
Incoherent considerations aren’t all that bad. Even if someone prefers A to B, B to C, and C to A, they’ll just spend a lot of time switching rather than waiting to die. I guess that people probably prefer changing their considerations in general, so your example of a semi-random consideration is sufficient but not at all unique or uncommon.
Sure, unless one of the semi-random considerations that moves you is “Crap, my EV is not coherent. Well I don’t want to lay down and wait to die, so let’s just make an AI that will serve my current desires.” :)
Incoherent considerations aren’t all that bad. Even if someone prefers A to B, B to C, and C to A, they’ll just spend a lot of time switching rather than waiting to die. I guess that people probably prefer changing their considerations in general, so your example of a semi-random consideration is sufficient but not at all unique or uncommon.