Do you think Gardner’s theory solves the problem Phil puts forth? If so, how? Or are you saying “maybe it solves it, maybe it doesn’t, but it’s related, so let’s look at it for extra insight into the problem”?
Ah, right. Let me clarify. I’m just saying that it’s clearly related. Lots of relevant research on this question has been done in the context of Gardner’s theory.
I am skeptical of the claim that Gardner has a theory. Lots of papers cite Gardner, but I am skeptical of the claim that it is useful to label them “research.”
Do you think Gardner’s theory solves the problem Phil puts forth? If so, how? Or are you saying “maybe it solves it, maybe it doesn’t, but it’s related, so let’s look at it for extra insight into the problem”?
Ah, right. Let me clarify. I’m just saying that it’s clearly related. Lots of relevant research on this question has been done in the context of Gardner’s theory.
I am skeptical of the claim that Gardner has a theory. Lots of papers cite Gardner, but I am skeptical of the claim that it is useful to label them “research.”