Thanks for this! People interested in the claim (which Korsgaard takes to be a deficiency of utilitarianism) that for utilitarians “people and animals don’t really matter at all; they are just the place where the valuable things happen”, might be interested in Richard Yetter Chappell’s [1] paper “Value Receptacles” (pdf). It’s an exploration of what this claim could even mean, and a defense of utilitarianism in light of it.
[1] Not incidentally, a long-time effective altruist. Whose blog is great.
Thanks for this! People interested in the claim (which Korsgaard takes to be a deficiency of utilitarianism) that for utilitarians “people and animals don’t really matter at all; they are just the place where the valuable things happen”, might be interested in Richard Yetter Chappell’s [1] paper “Value Receptacles” (pdf). It’s an exploration of what this claim could even mean, and a defense of utilitarianism in light of it.
[1] Not incidentally, a long-time effective altruist. Whose blog is great.
I know the author and the blog but didn’t know the paper, thanks!