Should that topic be taught in AP history? I don’t know.
If so, how? According to the AP history test. My search just now only showed “AP US history”, so if that’s the AP history in question, it would be in relation to US involvement.
If not, why? Potential good reasons not to discuss the issue, if they are true: It’s not related to the test they’re preparing for. It’s a divisive issue for the students. Divisive issues distract from the goals of the class.
OK so I’ve laid out the potential pros and cons for discussing Israel-Palestine in an AP class. If you figure out how truthful each pro and con is, then the answer to the original question should be obvious.
I agree that audience score seems to be a better signal than critics score, but neither works consistently.