I asked Leah about participating in her test. I think I will find it challenging the emulate a Christian’s viewpoint, instead of mocking it.
That is, normally when I’ve examined Christian thought, I’ve approached it from the pretense “let me see where this fails.”
I’m interested to see if I can construct an argument that I myself as an atheist would find at least superficially compelling—that is, I want to avoid doing what pretty much every popular Christianity book does.
Voting for the Christian / “Christian” half is open—see Leah’s site.
I had fun figuring these out. Once it’s done I’d be interested to see what criteria LW users used to determine someone’s real beliefs...