I think that scenario has downsides, but overall, if forced to give it a single label, I’d say it’s good. People live as long as they want, it just turns out they don’t want to live that long.
Or at least it depends on how you interpret it. If you interpret it as “it turns out people don’t actually want to live that long”, then arguably that’s a fact which we’re taking as given, and to which the judgement of whether this is a good or a bad scenario doesn’t apply. Given that humans don’t to live that long, is it good that they can live as long as they want, and no more? Yes!
I think that scenario has downsides, but overall, if forced to give it a single label, I’d say it’s good. People live as long as they want, it just turns out they don’t want to live that long.
Or at least it depends on how you interpret it. If you interpret it as “it turns out people don’t actually want to live that long”, then arguably that’s a fact which we’re taking as given, and to which the judgement of whether this is a good or a bad scenario doesn’t apply. Given that humans don’t to live that long, is it good that they can live as long as they want, and no more? Yes!