It took a minute to “click” for me that the green up marks and red down marks corresponded to each other in four opposed pairs, and that the Truth/Aim/Clarity numbers also corresponded to these axes. Possibly this is because I went straight to the thread after quickly skimming the OP, but most threads won’t have the OP to explain things anyway. So my impression is it should be less opaque somehow. I do like having votes convey a lot more information than up/down. I wonder if it would be best to hide the new features under some sort of “advanced options” interface.
“Seeks truth” and “seeks conflict” aren’t always opposites. For example, it’s common for comments to seek harmony instead of either truth or conflict.
If there’s going to be a small number of emojis, they should probably be very different colors, like red/yellow/blue/green.
It took a minute to “click” for me that the green up marks and red down marks corresponded to each other in four opposed pairs, and that the Truth/Aim/Clarity numbers also corresponded to these axes. Possibly this is because I went straight to the thread after quickly skimming the OP, but most threads won’t have the OP to explain things anyway. So my impression is it should be less opaque somehow. I do like having votes convey a lot more information than up/down. I wonder if it would be best to hide the new features under some sort of “advanced options” interface.
“Seeks truth” and “seeks conflict” aren’t always opposites. For example, it’s common for comments to seek harmony instead of either truth or conflict.
If there’s going to be a small number of emojis, they should probably be very different colors, like red/yellow/blue/green.