TsviBT comments on The Game Board has been Flipped: Now is a good time to rethink what you’re doing

[TsviBT]

we already have AI that does every qualitative kind of thing you say AIs qualitatively can’t do

As I mentioned, my response is here https://​​www.lesswrong.com/​​posts/​​sTDfraZab47KiRMmT/​​views-on-when-agi-comes-and-on-strategy-to-reduce#_We_just_need_X__intuitions:

just because an idea is, at a high level, some kind of X, doesn’t mean the idea is anything like the fully-fledged, generally applicable version of X that one imagines when describing X

I haven’t heard a response /​ counterargument to this yet, and many people keep making this logic mistake, including AFAICT you.