I think all three of us are right and secretly all agree.
(1) that weirdness points are bayesian evidence of being wrong (surely timecube doesn’t seem more accurate because no one believes it). Normal stuff is wrong quite a lot but not more wrong than guessing.
(2) weirdness points can never give you enough certainty to dismiss an issue completely. Time Cube is wrong because it is Time Cube (read: insane ramblings), not because it’s unpopular. Of course we don’t have a duty to research all unlikely things, but if we already are thinking about it, “it’s weird” isn’t a good/rational place to stop, unless you want to just do something else, like eat a banana or go to the park or something.
and, critically, (3) If you don’t have evidence enough to completely swamp and replace the bayesian update from weirdness points, you really don’t have enough evidence to contribute a whole lot to any search for truth. That’s what I was getting at. It’s also pretty unlikely that the weirdness that “weirdness points” refer to would be unknown to someone you’re talking with.
I think all three of us are right and secretly all agree.
(1) that weirdness points are bayesian evidence of being wrong (surely timecube doesn’t seem more accurate because no one believes it). Normal stuff is wrong quite a lot but not more wrong than guessing.
(2) weirdness points can never give you enough certainty to dismiss an issue completely. Time Cube is wrong because it is Time Cube (read: insane ramblings), not because it’s unpopular. Of course we don’t have a duty to research all unlikely things, but if we already are thinking about it, “it’s weird” isn’t a good/rational place to stop, unless you want to just do something else, like eat a banana or go to the park or something.
and, critically, (3) If you don’t have evidence enough to completely swamp and replace the bayesian update from weirdness points, you really don’t have enough evidence to contribute a whole lot to any search for truth. That’s what I was getting at. It’s also pretty unlikely that the weirdness that “weirdness points” refer to would be unknown to someone you’re talking with.