I think I don’t follow everything you’re saying in this comment; sorry. A few things: - We do have lower p(AI takeover) than lots of folks—and higher than lots of other folks. But I think even if your p(AI takeover) is much higher, it’s unclear that centralisation is good, for some of the reasons we give in the post: -- race dynamics with China might get worse and increase AI takeover risk —racing between western projects might not be a big deal in comparison, because of races to the top and being more easily able to regulate - I’m not trying to assume that China couldn’t catch up to the US. I think it’s plausible that China could do this in either world via stealing the model weights, or if timelines are long. Maybe it could also catch up without those things if it put its whole industrial might behind the problem (which it might be motivated to do in the wake of US centralisation). - I think whether a human dictatorship is better or worse than an AI dictatorship isn’t obvious (and that some dictatorships could be worse than extinction)
Thanks!
I think I don’t follow everything you’re saying in this comment; sorry. A few things:
- We do have lower p(AI takeover) than lots of folks—and higher than lots of other folks. But I think even if your p(AI takeover) is much higher, it’s unclear that centralisation is good, for some of the reasons we give in the post:
-- race dynamics with China might get worse and increase AI takeover risk
—racing between western projects might not be a big deal in comparison, because of races to the top and being more easily able to regulate
- I’m not trying to assume that China couldn’t catch up to the US. I think it’s plausible that China could do this in either world via stealing the model weights, or if timelines are long. Maybe it could also catch up without those things if it put its whole industrial might behind the problem (which it might be motivated to do in the wake of US centralisation).
- I think whether a human dictatorship is better or worse than an AI dictatorship isn’t obvious (and that some dictatorships could be worse than extinction)