The reason I trust research in physics in general is that it doesn’t end with publishing a paper. It often ends with building machines that depend on that research being right.
We don’t just “trust the science” that light is a wave; we use microwave ovens at home.
Well said. I’m gonna have to steal that.
Therefore, in a world where we all do power poses all the time, and if you forget to do them, you will predictably fail the exam...
...well, actually that could just be a placebo effect.
Yeah, “Can I fail my exam” is a bad test, because when the test is “can I fail” then it’s easy for the theory to be “wrong in the right way”. GPS is a good test of GR because you just can’t do it without a better understanding of spacetime so it has to at least get something right even if it’s not the full picture. When you actually use the resulting technology in your day to day life and get results you couldn’t have gotten before, then it almost doesn’t matter what the scientific literature says, because “I would feel sorry for the good Lord. The theory is correct.”.
There are psychological equivalents of this, which rest on doing things that are simply beyond the abilities of people who lack this understanding. The “NLP fast phobia cure” is a perfect example of this, and I can provide citations if anyone is interested. I really get a kick out of the predictable arguments between those who “trust the science” but don’t understand it, and those who actually do it on a regular basis.
(Something like seeing a black cat on your way to exam, freaking out about it, and failing to pay full attention to the exam.) Damn!
This reminds me of an amusing anecdote.
I had a weird experience once where I got my ankle sprained pretty bad and found myself simultaneously indignantly deciding that my ankle wasn’t going to swell and also thinking I was crazy for feeling like swelling was a thing I could control—and it didn’t swell. I told my friend about this experience, and while she was skeptical and thought it sounded crazy, she tried it anyway and her next several injuries didn’t swell.
Eventually she casually mentioned to someone “Nah, my broken thumb isn’t going to swell because I decided not to”, and the person she was talking to responded as if she had said something else because his brain just couldn’t register what she actually said as a real possibility. She then got all self conscious about it and was kinda unintentionally gaslighted into feeling like she was crazy for thinking she could do that, and her thumb swelled up.
I had to call her and remind her “No, you don’t give up and expect it to swell because it ‘sounds crazy’, you intend for it to not swell anyway and find out whether it is something you can control or not”. The swelling went back down most of the way after that, though not to the same degree as in the previous cases where the injury never swelled in the first place.
Well said. I’m gonna have to steal that.
Yeah, “Can I fail my exam” is a bad test, because when the test is “can I fail” then it’s easy for the theory to be “wrong in the right way”. GPS is a good test of GR because you just can’t do it without a better understanding of spacetime so it has to at least get something right even if it’s not the full picture. When you actually use the resulting technology in your day to day life and get results you couldn’t have gotten before, then it almost doesn’t matter what the scientific literature says, because “I would feel sorry for the good Lord. The theory is correct.”.
There are psychological equivalents of this, which rest on doing things that are simply beyond the abilities of people who lack this understanding. The “NLP fast phobia cure” is a perfect example of this, and I can provide citations if anyone is interested. I really get a kick out of the predictable arguments between those who “trust the science” but don’t understand it, and those who actually do it on a regular basis.
This reminds me of an amusing anecdote.
I had a weird experience once where I got my ankle sprained pretty bad and found myself simultaneously indignantly deciding that my ankle wasn’t going to swell and also thinking I was crazy for feeling like swelling was a thing I could control—and it didn’t swell. I told my friend about this experience, and while she was skeptical and thought it sounded crazy, she tried it anyway and her next several injuries didn’t swell.
Eventually she casually mentioned to someone “Nah, my broken thumb isn’t going to swell because I decided not to”, and the person she was talking to responded as if she had said something else because his brain just couldn’t register what she actually said as a real possibility. She then got all self conscious about it and was kinda unintentionally gaslighted into feeling like she was crazy for thinking she could do that, and her thumb swelled up.
I had to call her and remind her “No, you don’t give up and expect it to swell because it ‘sounds crazy’, you intend for it to not swell anyway and find out whether it is something you can control or not”. The swelling went back down most of the way after that, though not to the same degree as in the previous cases where the injury never swelled in the first place.