I wish you’d made this a top-level post; the ultra-long quote excerpts in a comment made it ~unreadable to me. And you don’t benefit from stuff like bigger font size or automatic table of contents. And scrolling to the correct position on this long comment thread also works poorly, etc.
Anyway, I read your rebuttals on the first two points and did not find them persuasive (thus resulting in a strong disagree-vote on the whole comment). So now I’m curious about the upvotes without accompanying discussion. Did others find this rebuttal more persuasive?
I wish you’d made this a top-level post; the ultra-long quote excerpts in a comment made it ~unreadable to me. And you don’t benefit from stuff like bigger font size or automatic table of contents. And scrolling to the correct position on this long comment thread also works poorly, etc.
Anyway, I read your rebuttals on the first two points and did not find them persuasive (thus resulting in a strong disagree-vote on the whole comment). So now I’m curious about the upvotes without accompanying discussion. Did others find this rebuttal more persuasive?
I made this a top level post, and fixed the formatting and quoting:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/wkFQ8kDsZL5Ytf73n/my-disagreements-with-agi-ruin-a-list-of-lethalities