First two ingredients specify the potion, remaining three make it juuust impossible enough to guarantee that it will reliably be magical without going boom.
After some consideration (and reading other people’s answers, in particular simon’s) I’ve come to the conclusion that the best answer to give is actually
Thanks for running this!
Unless I made some trivial mistake,
Crushed Onyx, Ground Bone, Demon Claw, Giant’s Toe, Vampire Fang
should work.
Explanation:
First two ingredients specify the potion, remaining three make it juuust impossible enough to guarantee that it will reliably be magical without going boom.
After some consideration (and reading other people’s answers, in particular simon’s) I’ve come to the conclusion that the best answer to give is actually
Vampire Fang, Troll Blood, Ground Bone, Oaken Twigs, Demon Claw