Hmm. So, what I was attempting to say was not that Jacob’s post would convince you to like the postrat scene.
More that it would help you to understand the postrat scene.
Moreover, I can imagine two categories of people who have negative opinions about the scene:
People who think it’s stupid because it’s shallow (not sure shallow is the right word here).
People who think it’s stupid because it appears shallow but know that the decoder ring for stuff like the QAnon post exists.
I’d say that when I said:
On the other hand, it feels like it it is helpful explaining to people who already have some sort of idea that the scene exists and posts and already have some sort of at least slightly negative opinion about it.
I was saying that it feels like the post would be most effective at moving people from category 1 to category 2.
FWIW, I’m mostly of the same opinion as you WRT to stuff like the QAnon tweet though I would express my emotional reaction more as indifference/you-do-you than disgust.
What I find interesting is that when I was in my teens through my twenties, I would have reveled in this ingroup type of stuff. I did revel in it! Now that I’m in my mid 40s I have an almost allergic reaction to it.
More that it would help you to understand the postrat scene.
I see, thanks for clarifying. I think it helped me understand the postrat scene (although I have no interest in verifying that), so in that sense the post was successful.
FWIW, I’m mostly of the same opinion as you WRT to stuff like the QAnon tweet though I would express my emotional reaction more as indifference/you-do-you than disgust.
What I find interesting is that when I was in my teens through my twenties, I would have reveled in this ingroup type of stuff. I did revel in it! Now that I’m in my mid 40s I have an almost allergic reaction to it.
I’m somewhat confused on what you actually feel here, since “allergic reaction” seems very similar to my reaction: aversive for yourself. To be clear, I’m perfectly happy with the postrat scene doing its thing so long as it leaves the things I care about alone. I’m a strong supporter of liberalism in the sense of letting others do whatever they want so long as it isn’t directly harmful to people who are not themselves involved.
I’m somewhat confused on what you actually feel here
If I was to immerse myself in postrat, I would not like it because I prefer to be doing things that I enjoy and think are good and useful. If I was forced to be immersed in postrat I’d be bored, bemused, indifferent. I have a hard time thinking of a way that the word “disgust” would be used to describe my reaction.
Hmm. So, what I was attempting to say was not that Jacob’s post would convince you to like the postrat scene.
More that it would help you to understand the postrat scene.
Moreover, I can imagine two categories of people who have negative opinions about the scene:
People who think it’s stupid because it’s shallow (not sure shallow is the right word here).
People who think it’s stupid because it appears shallow but know that the decoder ring for stuff like the QAnon post exists.
I’d say that when I said:
I was saying that it feels like the post would be most effective at moving people from category 1 to category 2.
FWIW, I’m mostly of the same opinion as you WRT to stuff like the QAnon tweet though I would express my emotional reaction more as indifference/you-do-you than disgust.
What I find interesting is that when I was in my teens through my twenties, I would have reveled in this ingroup type of stuff. I did revel in it! Now that I’m in my mid 40s I have an almost allergic reaction to it.
I see, thanks for clarifying. I think it helped me understand the postrat scene (although I have no interest in verifying that), so in that sense the post was successful.
I’m somewhat confused on what you actually feel here, since “allergic reaction” seems very similar to my reaction: aversive for yourself. To be clear, I’m perfectly happy with the postrat scene doing its thing so long as it leaves the things I care about alone. I’m a strong supporter of liberalism in the sense of letting others do whatever they want so long as it isn’t directly harmful to people who are not themselves involved.
If I was to immerse myself in postrat, I would not like it because I prefer to be doing things that I enjoy and think are good and useful. If I was forced to be immersed in postrat I’d be bored, bemused, indifferent. I have a hard time thinking of a way that the word “disgust” would be used to describe my reaction.
I’m allergic to being bored.