Update: Posts need at least 2 nominations to proceed to the Review Phase.
I initially left this requirement as a somewhat vague “sufficient nominations”, because I wasn’t sure how many people would be engaging with the process and how thoroughly. I’m less worried about that now, and meanwhile I think it’s there’s a fairly substantial shift between “at least one person liked this and took time to say so” to “at least two people liked it.”
(The goal is still to have the Review Phase include 50-100 posts, which could potentially mean the nomination-requirement goes even higher, although I think that’s unlikely)
Meanwhile, it’s still the case that:
It’s okay to leave short nominations (that might link to an existing nomination-comment saying ‘what they said’)
It’s still useful to have as many concrete details about how the post has been useful, as possible. (i.e. order of magnitude of number of conversations/projects/decisions that the post was useful to, and roughly estimating the magnitude of how useful it was)
(Also note: in another hour or two some new UI will launch that tells you the number of nominations each post has on the nominations page, which should make the process a bit easier)
Update: Posts need at least 2 nominations to proceed to the Review Phase.
I initially left this requirement as a somewhat vague “sufficient nominations”, because I wasn’t sure how many people would be engaging with the process and how thoroughly. I’m less worried about that now, and meanwhile I think it’s there’s a fairly substantial shift between “at least one person liked this and took time to say so” to “at least two people liked it.”
(The goal is still to have the Review Phase include 50-100 posts, which could potentially mean the nomination-requirement goes even higher, although I think that’s unlikely)
Meanwhile, it’s still the case that:
It’s okay to leave short nominations (that might link to an existing nomination-comment saying ‘what they said’)
It’s still useful to have as many concrete details about how the post has been useful, as possible. (i.e. order of magnitude of number of conversations/projects/decisions that the post was useful to, and roughly estimating the magnitude of how useful it was)
(Also note: in another hour or two some new UI will launch that tells you the number of nominations each post has on the nominations page, which should make the process a bit easier)