“The real question is when “Because Eliezer said so!” became a valid moral argument.”
You’re confusing the algorithm Eliezer is trying to approximate with the real, physical Eliezer. If Eliezer was struck by a cosmic ray tomorrow and became a serial killer, me, you, and Eliezer would all agree that this doesn’t make being a serial killer right.
“The real question is when “Because Eliezer said so!” became a valid moral argument.”
You’re confusing the algorithm Eliezer is trying to approximate with the real, physical Eliezer. If Eliezer was struck by a cosmic ray tomorrow and became a serial killer, me, you, and Eliezer would all agree that this doesn’t make being a serial killer right.