Why do people do this sort of experiment? Why do they deliberately try to create infectious plagues? Is there some real, useful knowledge that comes out of such experiments, or do they just want to see the world burn?
GoF research assists with vaccine development. Apparently that was the reasoning behind GoF research conducted on bat CoVs at the Wuhan Inst. of Virology.
And the results of all these experiments were lots of novel contagions and no vaccines. Complete and utter madness.
Well it’s hard to study something in theory. Making a plague—and using a procedure that could happen in nature it’s just improbable—allows for these scientists to play around with it and see how it works.
I think it’s research that should be done...in teleoperated labs in the middle of a hot desert or other wasteland free of hosts to spread it...
Viruses are known to sometimes jump from one species to another, so what is different about how they are encouraged to do so in a lab? Are they doing anything but forcing it to happen faster?
I am not a biologist and this is wild speculation, but I wonder if, when you force pathogens to pass from one host species to another to another to another, are you selecting them not just for making each individual jump, but for being able to jump from any species to any other more easily? You would then end up with a meta-infective virus able to mutate fast enough to spread through the whole animal kingdom and outpace any attempts at vaccination.
Fortunately such a meta virus that can kill everything is probably difficult to produce from the set of amino acids shared in common to life on earth.
(This is essentially what a gray goo scenario is—life on earth is probably not maximally efficient and it is probably possible to build full synthetic organisms on the scale of cells that self replicate with optimized internal components)
Why do people do this sort of experiment? Why do they deliberately try to create infectious plagues? Is there some real, useful knowledge that comes out of such experiments, or do they just want to see the world burn?
GoF research assists with vaccine development. Apparently that was the reasoning behind GoF research conducted on bat CoVs at the Wuhan Inst. of Virology.
And the results of all these experiments were lots of novel contagions and no vaccines. Complete and utter madness.
https://www.nature.com/news/engineered-bat-virus-stirs-debate-over-risky-research-%201.18787#/b1
Well it’s hard to study something in theory. Making a plague—and using a procedure that could happen in nature it’s just improbable—allows for these scientists to play around with it and see how it works.
I think it’s research that should be done...in teleoperated labs in the middle of a hot desert or other wasteland free of hosts to spread it...
Viruses are known to sometimes jump from one species to another, so what is different about how they are encouraged to do so in a lab? Are they doing anything but forcing it to happen faster?
I am not a biologist and this is wild speculation, but I wonder if, when you force pathogens to pass from one host species to another to another to another, are you selecting them not just for making each individual jump, but for being able to jump from any species to any other more easily? You would then end up with a meta-infective virus able to mutate fast enough to spread through the whole animal kingdom and outpace any attempts at vaccination.
They are forcing it to happen a lot faster, yes.
Fortunately such a meta virus that can kill everything is probably difficult to produce from the set of amino acids shared in common to life on earth. (This is essentially what a gray goo scenario is—life on earth is probably not maximally efficient and it is probably possible to build full synthetic organisms on the scale of cells that self replicate with optimized internal components)