I think you need evidence about what effect non-tug of war voting has.
Suppose I support the free ownership of weapons, but think a seven day waiting period is better than none.
If I vote for that waiting period, am I demoralising my fellow gun supporters, and invigorating the gun control types, who will therefore struggle harder for more restrictions? Or invigorating my side, which will make sure it does not get defeated next time? Too little evidence to make a prediction.
Or what if I say, well, seven days is OK, but if they win this the gun control types will then demand gun licencing, involving gun holders needing annual psychiatrist’s reports. So I have to tug against seven days, in case something worse comes along.
I would vote for the policy I supported. This has little enough effect on whether that policy gets made into law. I would think the effect on future changes is more negligible.
As a British citizen, I have never been eligible to vote in a referendum. It seems that American propositions are much more common.
Less Wrong SF quote: “The right to bear weapons is the right to be free”- The Weapon Shops of Isher.
I think you need evidence about what effect non-tug of war voting has.
Suppose I support the free ownership of weapons, but think a seven day waiting period is better than none.
If I vote for that waiting period, am I demoralising my fellow gun supporters, and invigorating the gun control types, who will therefore struggle harder for more restrictions? Or invigorating my side, which will make sure it does not get defeated next time? Too little evidence to make a prediction.
Or what if I say, well, seven days is OK, but if they win this the gun control types will then demand gun licencing, involving gun holders needing annual psychiatrist’s reports. So I have to tug against seven days, in case something worse comes along.
I would vote for the policy I supported. This has little enough effect on whether that policy gets made into law. I would think the effect on future changes is more negligible.
As a British citizen, I have never been eligible to vote in a referendum. It seems that American propositions are much more common.
Less Wrong SF quote: “The right to bear weapons is the right to be free”- The Weapon Shops of Isher.