i have tended to think that the stuff with “intellectual-glamour” or “visionary” branding is actually pretty close to on-target. not always right, of course, often overhyped, but often still underinvested in even despite being highly hyped.
(a surprising number of famous scientists are starved for funding. a surprising number of inventions featured on TED, NYT, etc were never given resources to scale.)
I also am literally unconvinced that “Europe’s kindergarten” was less sophisticated than our own time! but it seems like a fine debate to have at leisure, not totally sure how it would play out.
he’s basically been proven right that energy has moved “underground” but that’s not a mode i can work very effectively in. if you have to be invited to participate, well, it’s probably not going to happen for me.
at the institutional level, he’s probably right that it’s wise to prepare for bad times and not get complacent. again, this was 2019; a lot of the bad times came later. i miss the good times; i want to believe they’ll come again.
links 9/14/2024: https://roamresearch.com/#/app/srcpublic/page/11-14-2024
https://archive.org/details/byte-magazine retro magazines
https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2019/09/17/weirding-diary-10/#more-6737 Venkatesh Rao on the fall of the MIT Media Lab
this stung a bit!
i have tended to think that the stuff with “intellectual-glamour” or “visionary” branding is actually pretty close to on-target. not always right, of course, often overhyped, but often still underinvested in even despite being highly hyped.
(a surprising number of famous scientists are starved for funding. a surprising number of inventions featured on TED, NYT, etc were never given resources to scale.)
I also am literally unconvinced that “Europe’s kindergarten” was less sophisticated than our own time! but it seems like a fine debate to have at leisure, not totally sure how it would play out.
he’s basically been proven right that energy has moved “underground” but that’s not a mode i can work very effectively in. if you have to be invited to participate, well, it’s probably not going to happen for me.
at the institutional level, he’s probably right that it’s wise to prepare for bad times and not get complacent. again, this was 2019; a lot of the bad times came later. i miss the good times; i want to believe they’ll come again.