At dinner the man bragged that Yudkowsky had modeled a core HPMOR professor on him.
Like… an actual evil amoral BBEG wizard? Is this something true rationalists now brag about? Just because someone uses rationality toolset doesn’t make them role model :(
I wouldn’t trust the news articles to mention this accurately. Separately HPMOR was also not over back then, so it is plausible that Michael owned himself by bragging about this before the professors real identity was revealed.
It didn’t have to be revealed. That Quirrel was Voldemort was obvious almost within the first chapter introducing him (eg already taken for granted in the earliest top-level discussion page in 2010), to the extent that fandebate over ‘Quirrelmort’ was mostly “he’s so obviously Voldemort, just like in canon—but surely Yudkowsky would never make it that easy, so could he possibly be someone or something else? An impostor? some sort of diary-like upload? a merger of Quirrel/Voldemort? Harry from the future?” Bragging about being the inspiration for a character so nakedly amoral, at best, that the defense in fan debates is “he’s too evil to be Voldemort!” is not a great look no matter when in the series he was doing that bragging.
Like… an actual evil amoral BBEG wizard? Is this something true rationalists now brag about?
Just because someone uses rationality toolset doesn’t make them role model :(
I wouldn’t trust the news articles to mention this accurately. Separately HPMOR was also not over back then, so it is plausible that Michael owned himself by bragging about this before the professors real identity was revealed.
It didn’t have to be revealed. That Quirrel was Voldemort was obvious almost within the first chapter introducing him (eg already taken for granted in the earliest top-level discussion page in 2010), to the extent that fandebate over ‘Quirrelmort’ was mostly “he’s so obviously Voldemort, just like in canon—but surely Yudkowsky would never make it that easy, so could he possibly be someone or something else? An impostor? some sort of diary-like upload? a merger of Quirrel/Voldemort? Harry from the future?” Bragging about being the inspiration for a character so nakedly amoral, at best, that the defense in fan debates is “he’s too evil to be Voldemort!” is not a great look no matter when in the series he was doing that bragging.