Yeah, I’m not making any object level claims about this post one way or another, just thinking about the general principles.
Thinking a bit more:
I think the Review does fairly naturally make a schelling time for people to write up more top-level responses on things they disagree with. I think it’s probably important for it to be possible to write reviews on posts during the Review unless the author specifically removes it from consideration in the Review (which maybe should be special-cased, and doesn’t mean people can write more back-and-forth comments, just write a top level review).
(that’s still me musing-out-loud, not like making a final decision, but I will think about it more)
Yeah, I’m not making any object level claims about this post one way or another, just thinking about the general principles.
Thinking a bit more:
I think the Review does fairly naturally make a schelling time for people to write up more top-level responses on things they disagree with. I think it’s probably important for it to be possible to write reviews on posts during the Review unless the author specifically removes it from consideration in the Review (which maybe should be special-cased, and doesn’t mean people can write more back-and-forth comments, just write a top level review).
(that’s still me musing-out-loud, not like making a final decision, but I will think about it more)