My kids are still very young, so they’re not self-sufficient readers yet, but they really like story-time, so it’s looking good that they’ll grow up into book lovers (and I’m sure they got book-lover genes from my wife and I ;).
I don’t see TV as inherently bad—in fact, some of the kids programming on Treehouse in Canada is quite good! It’s just a tool that is particularly prone to misuse.
As an aside—one of the shows “Guess with Jess” teaches a kid-version of hypothesis formation and testing and inferential reasoning.
I don’t see TV as inherently bad—in fact, some of the kids programming on Treehouse in Canada is quite good!
I’ve sometimes regretted not watching TV for this reason. When I was in seventh grade, my friend called me ‘culturally deprived’. A lot of kids watched the same TV shows and talked about them, and I didn’t get the references. Whereas up until high school, hardly anyone had read the same books that I had. In a way, I was excluded from pop culture. And my general knowledge in areas that don’t specifically interest me, like politics, is probably much lower as a result of not having been plunked in front of educational shows.
Still, I think that not having the habit of watching TV to relax outweighs those downsides. I’m able to get a lot more done in the time I don’t spend watching TV.
I feel TV is inherently bad in some ways; one of my biggest concerns is that the way things are presented is artificial, designed to manipulate the viewer into thinking the way the creators of the show or commercial want him or her to think. Commercials are particularly bad.
Studies show (I don’t have the links, but I bet Google will find them) that there’s correlation between TV-watching time and propensity for violence and other bad behavior in children. I want to say it’s correlated with poorer academic performance as well, but I’m not sure if this was included or not.
That’s not causation, though. Parents who let their kids watch a lot of TV may also be less likely to act against bad behavior (by disciplining them, providing better models for behavior, and so forth). A large amount of TV-watching time could simply be an indicator of poor parenting, rather than the actual cause of bad behavior. I don’t know whether or not this is the case, but I’m wary of studies that only look at surface-level correlations.
Edit: However, after a bit of searching I found this page which summarizes several results that go beyond basic correlation.
one of my biggest concerns is that the way things are presented is artificial, designed to manipulate the viewer into thinking the way the creators of the show or commercial want him or her to think
This is true, but I’m pretty sanguine about it. The reality is, my kids are going to live in a world where they are exposed to media manipulation—protecting them from it at a young age isn’t going to encourage the kind of skepticism required to combat it later. Already, my almost-4-year-old seems to discount how awesome things look in a commercial due to past disappointments.
My kids are still very young, so they’re not self-sufficient readers yet, but they really like story-time, so it’s looking good that they’ll grow up into book lovers (and I’m sure they got book-lover genes from my wife and I ;).
I don’t see TV as inherently bad—in fact, some of the kids programming on Treehouse in Canada is quite good! It’s just a tool that is particularly prone to misuse.
As an aside—one of the shows “Guess with Jess” teaches a kid-version of hypothesis formation and testing and inferential reasoning.
I’ve sometimes regretted not watching TV for this reason. When I was in seventh grade, my friend called me ‘culturally deprived’. A lot of kids watched the same TV shows and talked about them, and I didn’t get the references. Whereas up until high school, hardly anyone had read the same books that I had. In a way, I was excluded from pop culture. And my general knowledge in areas that don’t specifically interest me, like politics, is probably much lower as a result of not having been plunked in front of educational shows.
Still, I think that not having the habit of watching TV to relax outweighs those downsides. I’m able to get a lot more done in the time I don’t spend watching TV.
I have trouble watching TV by myself without getting bored. It’s not interactive enough, or something. I need a book or a video game instead.
I feel TV is inherently bad in some ways; one of my biggest concerns is that the way things are presented is artificial, designed to manipulate the viewer into thinking the way the creators of the show or commercial want him or her to think. Commercials are particularly bad.
Studies show (I don’t have the links, but I bet Google will find them) that there’s correlation between TV-watching time and propensity for violence and other bad behavior in children. I want to say it’s correlated with poorer academic performance as well, but I’m not sure if this was included or not.
That’s not causation, though. Parents who let their kids watch a lot of TV may also be less likely to act against bad behavior (by disciplining them, providing better models for behavior, and so forth). A large amount of TV-watching time could simply be an indicator of poor parenting, rather than the actual cause of bad behavior. I don’t know whether or not this is the case, but I’m wary of studies that only look at surface-level correlations.
Edit: However, after a bit of searching I found this page which summarizes several results that go beyond basic correlation.
This is true, but I’m pretty sanguine about it. The reality is, my kids are going to live in a world where they are exposed to media manipulation—protecting them from it at a young age isn’t going to encourage the kind of skepticism required to combat it later. Already, my almost-4-year-old seems to discount how awesome things look in a commercial due to past disappointments.