Why people find it emotionally difficult to keep secrets?
The dynamic shows up very early in childhood (search for “google: louise ck secret”), it can involve self-sacrifice (confessing to a crime), and people find it relieving to share secrets even in completely anonymous and impersonal ways (“google: the confession bear meme”).
Secrets require cognitive effort. You need to keep track of what you can say to whom. Who told you what and when and why. It often involves lying or omitting information, both of which require additional effort and care in your conversation. I also find that it messes up some interpersonal relationships and habits. I’m not prone to keeping secrets and withholding information to my partner, family or friends, so if friend X tells me not to tell something to friend Y it forces me to act different from what feels natural.
I think it’s an evolved mechanism that favors group cooperation. If people feel emotionally motivated to be open and honest with each other, and maintain a history of doing so, they’re more trustworthy to each other and can coexist more peacefully and productively
Because they enjoy sharing info. Getting things “off their chests”. Having an extra mind to think about the issue. Getting help from people, which they are only able to give inasmuch as they are clued in. Having other people relate to the experience, or running a sanity check against them. Difficulty in maintaining the illusion of the contrary; especially when you’re lying about something that is essential to other people’s understanding of your true self, that’s basically life on hard mode. There are plenty of advantages, really, even in spite of incentives to keep some info secret.
Why people find it emotionally difficult to keep secrets?
The dynamic shows up very early in childhood (search for “google: louise ck secret”), it can involve self-sacrifice (confessing to a crime), and people find it relieving to share secrets even in completely anonymous and impersonal ways (“google: the confession bear meme”).
Secrets require cognitive effort. You need to keep track of what you can say to whom. Who told you what and when and why. It often involves lying or omitting information, both of which require additional effort and care in your conversation. I also find that it messes up some interpersonal relationships and habits. I’m not prone to keeping secrets and withholding information to my partner, family or friends, so if friend X tells me not to tell something to friend Y it forces me to act different from what feels natural.
I think it’s an evolved mechanism that favors group cooperation. If people feel emotionally motivated to be open and honest with each other, and maintain a history of doing so, they’re more trustworthy to each other and can coexist more peacefully and productively
Because they enjoy sharing info. Getting things “off their chests”. Having an extra mind to think about the issue. Getting help from people, which they are only able to give inasmuch as they are clued in. Having other people relate to the experience, or running a sanity check against them. Difficulty in maintaining the illusion of the contrary; especially when you’re lying about something that is essential to other people’s understanding of your true self, that’s basically life on hard mode. There are plenty of advantages, really, even in spite of incentives to keep some info secret.