With all due respect and truly no offense meant, I worry some commenters here may be missing Jaron’s position. He quickly appears to conclude that he cannot really discuss any issues with EY because they don’t even share the same premises. He makes this clear early on in his points on humanism and epistemology.
Jaron’s laughter seems largely the laughter of frustrated politesse. This comes out in his speech when he repeats to EY “I’ve been having this discussion for decades.” He appears to feel that his thinking has moved on, but EY’s may be stuck. He also says a couple of times “We could have a conversation about. . .this . . .or about . . .that,” which indicates his stoppage and almost a near-puzzlement with EY.
He wants to take EY at his word, but ultimately appears to conclude that he and EY have so little in common intellectually that he resorts to simply imploring EY to be a better scientist.
I first met Jaron more than a decade ago at the Knitting Factory and I must say I am surprised at how little he has changed—still so good-humored—I enjoy Jaron, so perhaps this colors my understanding. But it was sad to see the two talk past each other so much.
With all due respect and truly no offense meant, I worry some commenters here may be missing Jaron’s position. He quickly appears to conclude that he cannot really discuss any issues with EY because they don’t even share the same premises. He makes this clear early on in his points on humanism and epistemology.
Jaron’s laughter seems largely the laughter of frustrated politesse. This comes out in his speech when he repeats to EY “I’ve been having this discussion for decades.” He appears to feel that his thinking has moved on, but EY’s may be stuck. He also says a couple of times “We could have a conversation about. . .this . . .or about . . .that,” which indicates his stoppage and almost a near-puzzlement with EY.
He wants to take EY at his word, but ultimately appears to conclude that he and EY have so little in common intellectually that he resorts to simply imploring EY to be a better scientist.
I first met Jaron more than a decade ago at the Knitting Factory and I must say I am surprised at how little he has changed—still so good-humored—I enjoy Jaron, so perhaps this colors my understanding. But it was sad to see the two talk past each other so much.