This is why these arguments are not taken seriously.
Why should I (or anyone outside this circle) accept that this is a claim to be taken seriously? It sounds like you’ve found a fine metaphor that you believe can encompass any and all forms of mental activity and thus can “explain” anything put to it.
Freudian psychoanalysis can make the same claim to truth about the mind, of course, so you’ve offered up on rational case for why anyone should accept this as true.
Why should I (or anyone outside this circle) accept that this is a claim to be taken seriously?
Do you think this is a pretty piece of music? Please just listen to it, without being primed by the description, comments, or related videos; it’ll only take 2 minutes.
First, you claim that rationality is exclusive and ignores other legitimate fields of inquiry. Now, you claim that rationality is overly inclusive, trying to incorporate too many things. You’re a bit of an idiot.
This is why these arguments are not taken seriously.
Why should I (or anyone outside this circle) accept that this is a claim to be taken seriously? It sounds like you’ve found a fine metaphor that you believe can encompass any and all forms of mental activity and thus can “explain” anything put to it.
Freudian psychoanalysis can make the same claim to truth about the mind, of course, so you’ve offered up on rational case for why anyone should accept this as true.
See what happens when you ignore philosophy?
Do you think this is a pretty piece of music? Please just listen to it, without being primed by the description, comments, or related videos; it’ll only take 2 minutes.
I didn’t enjoy listening to it on its own terribly much, but I think it’d be OK as a soundtrack for a video or something.
First, you claim that rationality is exclusive and ignores other legitimate fields of inquiry. Now, you claim that rationality is overly inclusive, trying to incorporate too many things. You’re a bit of an idiot.
It’s almost like they aren’t mutually exclusive claims.
Show your calculations for this argument.