OK fair point. If we are going to use analogies, then my point #2 about a specific neural code shows our different positions I think.
Lets say we are trying to get a simple aircraft of the ground and we have detailed instructions for a large passenger jet. Our problem is that the metal is too weak and cannot be used to make wings, engines etc. In that case detailed plans for aircraft are no use, a single minded focus on getting better metal is what its all about. To me the neural code is like the metal and all the neuroscience is like the plane schematics. Note that I am wary of analogies—you obviously don’t see things like that or you wouldn’t have the position you do. Analogies can explain, but rarely persuade.
A more single minded focus on the neural code would be trying to watch neural connections form in real time while learning is happening. Fixed connectome scans of say mice can somewhat help with that, more direct control of dishbrain, watching the zebra fish brain would all count, however the details of neural biology that are specific to higher mammals would be ignored.
Its possible also that there is a hybrid process, that is the AI looks at all the ideas in the literature then suggests bio experiments to get things over the line.
OK fair point. If we are going to use analogies, then my point #2 about a specific neural code shows our different positions I think.
Lets say we are trying to get a simple aircraft of the ground and we have detailed instructions for a large passenger jet. Our problem is that the metal is too weak and cannot be used to make wings, engines etc. In that case detailed plans for aircraft are no use, a single minded focus on getting better metal is what its all about. To me the neural code is like the metal and all the neuroscience is like the plane schematics. Note that I am wary of analogies—you obviously don’t see things like that or you wouldn’t have the position you do. Analogies can explain, but rarely persuade.
A more single minded focus on the neural code would be trying to watch neural connections form in real time while learning is happening. Fixed connectome scans of say mice can somewhat help with that, more direct control of dishbrain, watching the zebra fish brain would all count, however the details of neural biology that are specific to higher mammals would be ignored.
Its possible also that there is a hybrid process, that is the AI looks at all the ideas in the literature then suggests bio experiments to get things over the line.