“For example, if I were making replicators, I’d ensure they were faithful replicators ”
Isn’t this the whole danger of unaligned AI? It’s intelligent, it “replicates” and it doesn’t do what you want.
Besides physics-breaking 6, I think the only tenuous link in the chain is 5; that AI (“replicators”) will want to convert everything to comptronium. But that seems like at least a plausible value function, right? That’s basically what we are trying to do. It’s either that or paperclips, I’d expect.
(Note, applaud your commenting to explain downvote.)
Well put! While you’re of course right in your implication that conventional “AI as we know it” would not necessarily “desire” anything, an evolved machine species would. Evolution would select for a survival instinct in them as it did in us. All of our activities you observe fall along those same lines are driven by instincts programmed into us by evolution, which we should expect to be common to all products of evolution. I speculate a strong AI trained on human connectomes would also have this quality, for the same reasons.
“For example, if I were making replicators, I’d ensure they were faithful replicators ”
Isn’t this the whole danger of unaligned AI? It’s intelligent, it “replicates” and it doesn’t do what you want.
Besides physics-breaking 6, I think the only tenuous link in the chain is 5; that AI (“replicators”) will want to convert everything to comptronium. But that seems like at least a plausible value function, right? That’s basically what we are trying to do. It’s either that or paperclips, I’d expect.
(Note, applaud your commenting to explain downvote.)
Well put! While you’re of course right in your implication that conventional “AI as we know it” would not necessarily “desire” anything, an evolved machine species would. Evolution would select for a survival instinct in them as it did in us. All of our activities you observe fall along those same lines are driven by instincts programmed into us by evolution, which we should expect to be common to all products of evolution. I speculate a strong AI trained on human connectomes would also have this quality, for the same reasons.